California Nonetheless in Drought? Sure, No and Perhaps — Half 2

Information Evaluation by Kip Hansen — 30 January 2023

There are claims that regardless of being flooded, washed away, landslided and buried in snow California is actually nonetheless in drought. Cliff Mass says that The California Drought is Over. Definitively.

In Half 1 of this two-part collection, I requested the query: “Is it potential that each declare and counter-claim are true?“ and answered, “Sure, very a lot so”.  And I informed readers the way it may very well be so.

What’s the drought scenario in California now, as of this week?

When you’ve learn Half 1 (and you actually ought to), you’ll not be shocked that the reply to this query is:

It relies on who you ask

Mark Arax, who writes about California and water, penned an Visitor Essay for the NY Instances’ Opinion part with the title: “My State Is 1,000 Miles Lengthy, and Not Everybody Residing in It Hates the Rain”.  The title provides his tackle the rain and the entire piece, filled with attention-grabbing historical past, is properly price studying.

The California Division of Water Assets simply made the following announcement:

Jan 26, 2023  SACRAMENTO, Calif. –The Division of Water Assets (DWR) right this moment introduced that latest storms will permit the State Water Mission (SWP) to spice up deliveries to 29 public water companies serving 27 million Californians. Primarily based on the quantity of water captured and saved in latest weeks, DWR now expects to ship 30 % of requested water provides – or 1.27 million acre-feet — in 2023, up from the preliminary 5 % introduced on December 1.

The allocation enhance is the direct results of excessive climate in late December and 9 atmospheric rivers in early January that helped fill reservoirs and dramatically enhance the Sierra Nevada snowpack. The SWP’s two largest reservoirs (Oroville and San Luis) have gained a mixed 1.62 million acre-feet of water in storage — roughly sufficient to supply water to five.6 million households for a yr. Whereas Water 12 months 2023 started with under common precipitation, situations shifted to excessive above common situations.”

Issues to notice:  The water division has elevated its anticipated water deliveries by an element of 6 – they may ship six occasions as a lot water.  However even with that massive enhance, it solely involves 30% of requested deliveries. (However that improves upon the depressing earlier estimate of 5% of requested.)  That represents the true situation of California’s water provide – demand is at all times far larger than provide.

As I defined in Half 1, drought is a really complicated and sophisticated subject, and is not only “not sufficient rain not too long ago”.  There isn’t any doubt that California’s drought scenario has vastly improved – they bought a number of rain and a number of snow within the mountains within the final two months.  However we nonetheless can not reply the query:  “Is California nonetheless in drought?” as a result of:

It relies on precisely what you ask and who you ask.

My answer to the conundrum of explaining California’s present drought scenario is simply to indicate photographs of varied drought-related indicators from a number of sources.  Readers are invited to reach at their very own conclusions.  I’m properly conscious that the bodily actuality on the bottom in California is not going to change primarily based on my or your opinions.

First, what’s the long-term common precipitation in California?

That is the 30-year common, one local weather interval, displaying the whole southwest  U.S.A.  I’ll pick some options, as you want to pay attention to this total sample to know right this moment’s California drought maps.

1) The Northwest-most nook of California, the purples,  is a temperate rain-forest, receives over 100 inches of rain per yr.

2)  There are a number of areas, the blues,  that obtain over 50 inches of rain with darker blues being 60-70 inches per yr.

3)  The greens are reasonably moist; southern Sierras, Huge Sur area, the excessive mountains surrounding the LA Basin.

4)  Guesstimating (every thing browner-than-yellow) 80% of California is dry to very dry.

In the present day, if we ask the California Division of Water Assets, we get this reply:

Notice:  A 12-month SPEI model.  About 50% of the state is in some form of drought, nonetheless.  The Colorado Desert, southeast-most nook, continues to be very dry – it bought virtually no rain within the latest storms.

The U.S. federal website,, provides us this most present view:

Notice:  That is present as much as 5 days in the past.  Enormous distinction between this and the picture simply above from California Water Watch. 

And once more,, with its Multi-Indicator Drought Index (MIDI):

Nonetheless extra disagreement – this reveals even a part of the Colorado Desert (decrease proper) as “W2” moist.

California’s saved water assets?  Its main reservoirs:

In spite of everything that rain, why aren’t all of them full? …and even as much as historic averages (inexperienced traces) ?  The primary reply is actual location.  Not all of the rain fell evenly in every single place in California.  Secondly, not each reservoir’s first precedence is to retain as a lot water as potential – they double as flood management gadgets, and should not be full if-and-when extra heavy rain comes.    The overall situation is that the reservoirs are in fine condition. [ see the California Department of Water Resources statement far above ]

Keep in mind, come April and Could, the snowpack begins to soften, generally very quickly.  A really speedy snow soften causes the creeks, streams and rivers to flood  — and the reservoirs will need to have room for all that further water.

That results in California Snowpack:  (see hyperlink for bigger picture)

Statewide averages:  128% of regular for 1 April (finish of the snow season – two months nonetheless to go during which to realize much more snow) and 214% of regular for this date.  The Southern Sierra, which incorporates Mount Whitney, is at 255% for this date.  That is water content material, not simply “toes of snow”.  Skiers care about snow base depth, however the water division cares about water content material.

In case your curiosity is in snowboarding, see this report of snow depths at California ski resorts:  virtually all report snow depths of over 100% of regular 1 April averages – with two moths of snow season but to go.

Now this one was a shock even to me, the Palmer Drought Index for California.  Be aware of the reason under the excerpted picture (taken from the nationwide map).

Groundwater is measured by vertical distance downward to the extent to the highest of the water column in a water properly. Groundwater is essential to Californians, lots of whom depend upon wells for his or her house’s consuming water and for California’s farmers and ranchers, who pump water up from wells to irrigate crops or water animals.

Low within the picture, simply above and a bit to the left of Los Angeles county, is a focus of pink dots indicating a water ranges of larger than 500 toes down till water could be discovered.  That is the southern San Joaquin Valley.  In complete, the valley produces about 13% of California’s agricultural output.  As a result of groundwater extraction over the past century,  the valley flooring has subsided by 20-30 toes (6 to 10 meters).

In chatting with a colleague not too long ago, she offered Lake Mead water stage as a “proof” of International Warming/Local weather Change.  The Lake Mead watershed solely features a tiny little bit of California.

That  very small a part of the Colorado Desert,  throughout the Colorado River watershed, is under Lake Mead and doesn’t feed into it.

As Cliff Mass clearly defined, and as is broadly understood, Lake Mead’s low water ranges are virtually completely all the way down to the truth that water withdrawals hold rising and at all times exceed water enter to the lake.  The 2 main reservoirs alongside the Colorado River, Lake Mead and Lake Powell, mixed should provide water to over 40 million folks.  Phoenix, Arizona alone has added an extra 500,000 folks because the flip of the century.  Enter into Lake Mead is very variable and has been rising ever so barely.

I supply one final set of photographs:  California Drought/Wetness because the flip to the 21st Century  and  the identical for the final 2,000 years.

Utilizing the eyeball check, we see that California has at all times been both very dry or fairly moist.  Numerous excessive years, each dry and moist, and so a few years within the +/- 20% vary. 

That’s California

# # # # #

Creator’s Remark:

It virtually by no means suffices to seize some seemingly wanting knowledge set off the web, bash it about till it’s compliant, graph it up, and current it as the-truth-the-whole-truth….

Many of the topics mentioned on this weblog simply aren’t that approach in the actual bodily world. 

Like “drought in California”.

I’d prefer to learn your opinions/conclusions, see any additional knowledge inputs you would possibly counsel, and reply any of your questions if I can.  Deal with your remark to “Kip” if chatting with me.

Thanks for studying,

# # # # #

Supply hyperlink

Subscribe to our newsletter
Sign up here to get the latest news, updates and special offers delivered directly to your inbox.
Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.